Legal information only — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Can Weaving and Drifting Onto the Shoulder Justify a Florida DUI Stop? Not Without a Safety Concern, the Second DCA Says

Swerving inside your own lane, or drifting onto the shoulder a few times, isn’t by itself enough for a Florida deputy to pull you over for suspected DUI — at least not in the Second District. The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed suppression of DUI evidence on October 30, 2026, in State v. Dunlop, No. 2D2025-1506, but flagged its own rule for the Florida Supreme Court to potentially revisit, certifying direct conflict with two other district courts. Judges Northcutt and Morris concurred; Chief Judge Lucas concurred in the result only, writing separately that he thinks the court’s own precedent gets the statute wrong.

What happened. A Manatee County deputy saw Joshua Dunlop’s truck swerve within its lane three or four times around midnight on State Road 64, then drift onto the shoulder three or four more times — at one point about halfway onto the shoulder. Unsure if Dunlop was tired or impaired, the deputy stopped him, leading to a DUI charge and a license-restriction violation.

Suppressed below, affirmed on appeal. The county court suppressed the stop, relying on the Second District’s 1998 ruling in Crooks v. State that a lane-maintenance violation requires evidence the driving created a reasonable safety concern — and finding Dunlop wasn’t driving erratically or aggressively and didn’t endanger anyone else. The State appealed, and the Second District affirmed, bound by its own precedent.

A chief judge pushes back. Chief Judge Lucas agreed with the result because the panel is bound by Crooks, but wrote separately that he thinks Crooks misread the statute from the start. He argued Florida’s lane-maintenance statute actually sets out two separate rules — stay in your lane as much as practicable, and don’t change lanes without first checking it’s safe — and that the safety-concern language only applies to the second rule, not the first. Under that reading, which the Fifth District already follows, a driver can violate the lane-maintenance statute by swerving alone, regardless of whether anyone was endangered.

What’s next. The panel certified its decision to be in direct conflict with the Sixth District’s Ramos Perez v. State and the Fifth District’s State v. Howard — teeing up the question of whether swerving alone justifies a DUI stop in Florida for the Florida Supreme Court to potentially take up. Certifying a conflict creates the opportunity for the Florida Supreme Court to review the question; it doesn’t mean the Court has agreed to.

Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)

Source: State v. Dunlop, No. 2D2025-1506 (Fla. 2d DCA Oct. 30, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.

Also on Florida Lawyer News: Does Swerving Within Your Lane Justify a Florida DUI Stop? Not Without a Safety Concern, the Second DCA Says – But Other Courts Disagree

Leave a Comment