Florida police do not always need a written policy to prove a vehicle inventory search was lawful — testimony that officers followed a standardized towing-and-inventory practice can be enough, as it was in this case. The Sixth District Court of Appeal so ruled on November 13, 2026, affirming a Lee County conviction in Broughton v. State, No. 6D2024-1193. Judge Smith wrote the opinion, joined by Chief Judge Traver and Judge Wozniak.
What happened. Fort Myers police arrested George S. Broughton, IV, for reckless driving. Because no other registered owner was available to take custody of the car, officers had it towed and searched it first. The search produced cocaine, a gun holster, and two handgun magazines. Broughton, previously convicted of a felony, pleaded no contest to reckless driving, cocaine possession, and possession of ammunition by a convicted felon, but preserved his right to challenge the denial of his motion to suppress.
The vehicle inventory search, without a written policy. Two Fort Myers officers testified at the suppression hearing. One said impoundment follows automatically “because the registered owner of the vehicle was placed under arrest,” that there is “no exception” allowing release of a vehicle “to anybody other than the registered owner,” and that an inventory search follows “for the safety of the belongings of the items and property inside of the vehicle.” A second officer confirmed towing and non-release to third parties are both department policy. No written policy document was ever introduced, and Broughton’s trial counsel called the testimony “conclusory.”
Why that was still enough. The court explained that an inventory search is lawful if conducted “in accordance with the governmental entity’s standardized operating procedure,” and that the State carries the burden of proving that standard exists. But neither the U.S. Supreme Court’s inventory-search cases, starting with South Dakota v. Opperman, nor Florida’s own precedent demand a particular quantity of proof. In Opperman, the only evidence was that an officer used “a standard inventory form pursuant to standard police procedures.” Florida’s Third District reached the same result in State v. Smith on testimony that never quoted a written policy at all.
Siding with the federal circuits. The panel went further, agreeing with multiple federal appellate courts that have held a law enforcement inventory policy “need not be in writing” at all, citing rulings from the Second, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Ninth Circuits. On that basis, the two officers’ testimony was “sufficient to … establish both the existence of an inventory search policy and that the policy was followed.”
What this does and does not mean. The court repeatedly described the officers’ testimony as “basic,” so this is not a high bar, but it is a real one — the State still has to put on some non-conclusory testimony about an actual towing-and-inventory practice. The court separately rejected, without much discussion, Broughton’s challenge to probable cause for the reckless driving arrest itself. The ruling does not reach closed-container inventory searches, which Florida courts analyze under a different line of cases. The opinion is not final until any timely motion for rehearing is resolved.
Related decisions: Can a Third Successive Postconviction Motion Stop a Death Warrant? No, the Florida Supreme Court Holds, Denying a Stay of Execution Can Prosecutors Appeal a Juvenile Disposition When the Judge Departs From the Plea Deal? Not Unless It Is Illegal, Says the First DCA
Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)
Source: Broughton v. State, No. 6D2024-1193 (Fla. 6th DCA Nov. 13, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.
Also on Florida Lawyer News: Does an Officer’s Testimony Alone Prove a Lawful Inventory Search Policy? Yes, Even Without a Written Document, the Sixth DCA Held
1 thought on “Do Police Need a Written Policy for a Vehicle Inventory Search? No, Testimony Alone Can Be Enough, Says Florida’s Sixth DCA”