Legal information only — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Does a Death Row Inmate Get a New Clemency Hearing Every Time His Sentence Is Reimposed? No, Florida’s Supreme Court Says

A death row inmate who received a clemency hearing in 1982, before his death sentence was later vacated and reimposed, is not entitled to a new clemency proceeding tied to that later sentence, the Florida Supreme Court held on October 8, 2026. The Court affirmed the summary denial of William Lee Thompson’s successive postconviction motion and denied his habeas corpus petition, in Thompson v. State, No. SC2026-1465, consolidated with Thompson v. Secretary, Department of Corrections, No. SC2026-1466. The per curiam opinion also rejected Thompson’s Eighth Amendment challenge to Florida’s lethal-injection protocol and his bid to revisit a decades-old intellectual-disability claim. Justice Tanenbaum concurred with an opinion; Justice Labarga concurred in part and dissented in part.

The 1976 murder. Thompson was sentenced to death for the 1976 torture-killing of Sally Ivester in a motel room. He has been resentenced to death twice since — in 1978 and again in 1989 — after earlier rounds of postconviction litigation, and his sentence became final in 1993.

A warrant, a competency inquiry, and a withdrawal the same day. Governor DeSantis signed Thompson’s death warrant on September 11, 2026, setting an October 13, 2026 execution date. On September 17, 2026, the Governor separately ordered a three-psychiatrist commission to evaluate whether Thompson is currently competent to be executed, and temporarily stayed the execution pending that commission’s report. The Court was careful to note this competency question is not what it decided: Thompson’s dementia claim, it said in a footnote, “bears on his present sanity to be executed — an issue distinct from his intellectual disability claim and not before this Court.” Hours after this ruling, on October 8, 2026, Governor DeSantis withdrew the death warrant entirely — his first warrant withdrawal since taking office. Thompson remains on death row with no execution currently scheduled.

No due-process right to a clemency hearing tied to this specific sentence. Thompson argued Florida denied him due process by never holding a clemency hearing specifically tied to his 1989 sentence. The Court held clemency is a matter of “unfettered discretion” under the Florida Constitution, that due process requires only minimal procedural safeguards for it, and — relying on its 1986 decision in Bundy v. State — that a prior clemency consideration need not be tied to the particular sentence being carried out. The record also showed Governor DeSantis considered and denied clemency before signing the current warrant. In a separate concurrence, Justice Tanenbaum added a further reason the claim fails: Florida law contemplates the defendant initiating any clemency request, and Thompson’s own postconviction motion did not show he ever applied for one.

Firing squad argument came too late. Thompson proposed execution by firing squad as a less painful alternative to lethal injection, citing his multiple medical conditions. The circuit court found he failed to show the alternative would meaningfully reduce the risk of pain, and the Supreme Court held Thompson waited until his reply brief to challenge that finding — too late to preserve the argument.

The dissent. Justice Labarga dissented from denying habeas relief on Thompson’s intellectual-disability claim, consistent with his long-standing position that Hall v. Florida should apply retroactively to sentences like Thompson’s that became final before Hall was decided. The majority held the issue was already settled by the Court’s 2022 ruling in the same case and could not be reopened as a “manifest injustice.”

Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)

Source: Thompson v. State, No. SC2026-1465, and Thompson v. Secretary, Department of Corrections, No. SC2026-1466 (Fla. Oct. 8, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.

Also on Florida Lawyer News: Does Florida Have to Hold a New Clemency Hearing Before Carrying Out an Old Death Warrant? No, the Supreme Court Says

Leave a Comment