Legal information only — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Does Raising New Incidents at a Domestic Violence Injunction Hearing Violate Due Process? Yes, the Sixth DCA Said, and Reversed

A trial court cannot use incidents that were never alleged in a domestic violence injunction petition to justify granting the injunction, if the respondent timely objects when those incidents come up for the first time at the final hearing. The Sixth District Court of Appeal reversed a five-year injunction on that ground on November 13, 2026, in Bayouth v. Reguero-Bayouth, No. 6D2025-0847, a per curiam opinion joined by Judges White, Smith, and Gannam.

Background. Lillian Reguero-Bayouth petitioned for a domestic violence injunction against Oliver K. Bayouth in Orange County. At the final hearing on her petition, she described incidents that were not in the petition itself. Bayouth’s attorney objected on the spot.

The due process problem. The trial court overruled the objection, and the hearing transcript showed it “relied, in part, upon these unpled incidents in deciding to issue the injunction.” The Sixth District held that was “a violation of Appellant’s due process rights and reversible error,” following three sister-district decisions, J.G.G. v. M.S., De Leon v. Collazo, and Sanchez v. Marin, each of which reversed an injunction for the same reason.

The domestic violence injunction’s fate. The court did not simply dismiss the petition. It reversed and sent the case back “with instructions to vacate the final injunction, reissue the temporary injunction, and conduct a new final hearing either on the existing petition or any properly amended petition.” That means Reguero-Bayouth can still pursue the injunction, including on the previously unpled incidents, as long as she puts them in the petition (or an amended one) before the new hearing. On remand, the trial court is to vacate the final injunction and put a temporary injunction back in place while the case awaits that new hearing.

What this does and does not mean. The opinion is brief and per curiam, with no discussion of what the unpled incidents actually were or why the petitioner raised them late. It says nothing about whether those incidents, properly pled, would support an injunction on the merits. The ruling is about procedure, not about whether Bayouth did or did not commit domestic violence. The opinion is not final until any timely motion for rehearing is resolved.

Related decisions: Do Police Need a Written Policy for a Vehicle Inventory Search? No, Testimony Alone Can Be Enough, Says Florida's Sixth DCA Can a Third Successive Postconviction Motion Stop a Death Warrant? No, the Florida Supreme Court Holds, Denying a Stay of Execution

Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)

Source: Bayouth v. Reguero-Bayouth, No. 6D2025-0847 (Fla. 6th DCA Nov. 13, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.

Also on Florida Lawyer News: Can a Domestic Violence Injunction Rest on Incidents Not in the Petition? No, the Sixth DCA Held, and Reversed

Leave a Comment